View Single Post
Old 30 January, 2009, 00:25 AM   #6 (permalink)
Will.Spencer Will.Spencer is online now
Gozer
 
Will.Spencer's Avatar
 
Location: Singapore
iTrader: (45)
Blog Entries: 1
Thanked 1,621 Times in 890 Posts
Posts: 4,951
$NetBucks: 8,223
Join Date: Dec 2008
Last Online: Yesterday 22:59 PM
Default

So where does that leave me, other than tired and frustrated?

Well, what are the options?

Drupal

No decent forum options! vBulletin integration is stuck at Drupal 5.x and Drupal's own forum code is unworthy.

Drupal's blogging options aren't the best.

The Drupal Blog Module provides member blogs under Drupal. This is better than what is provided under either Joomla or WordPress.

Drupal probably has the best community building options, but not the easiest.

Joomla

Joomla has weak integrations to vBulletin. If I chose Joomla I would probably downgrade to Fireboard instead of vBulletin -- just for the sake of tight integration with Community Builder.

Joomla can integrate with Wordpress or replace it with MyBlog.

Joomla has the easiest community building options.

Joomla can have member blogs with the addition of MyBlog or IDoBlog.

WordPress

This has the best forum integration with vBulletin, but leaves me with severely limited community building options.

The "Complete Wordpress/vBulletin Bridge" does not support Wordpress-Mu, so member blogs would be limited to vBBlog.

Summary

WordPress probably isn't going to work well as a primary CMS.

Drupal isn't going to work as a forum.

Joomla isn't the best at anything, but overall it appears to be the best option for everything.

Last edited by Will.Spencer; 7 September, 2009 at 04:57 AM..
  Reply With Quote